How we rate movies

 In Articles

I think that it is impossible to rate movies on an even playing field. Almost every reviewer that I watch uses a numeric scale or a lettered one but they apply it “evenly” to all films which is a mistake in my opinion. How can we compare movies that have very different goals? Not every director sets out to win best picture with every film and there is nothing wrong with that. And what even makes a good movie? There is no consensus as to what a good movie is and who am I to tell someone that their favorite movie is complete dog shit and that they do not know what they are talking about? Maybe we should tier films when we decide to rate them like put artsy films in one tier and blockbusters in a different one.

Recent Posts
Comments
  • Emily Frazee

    You make really great points about trying to compare movies on an even scale. Personally, I love comparing (which is often very difficult as you point out). I try my best to consider their goals as you mention and figure out what works and what doesn’t (for me). It’s definitely an extremely tricky thing to do, but I can’t help but try to find commonalities or unique aspects within films and try to figure out how they speak to me, if they even do. Some movies really are dog shit, and although it can be commonly recognized that way, there will always be /someone/ that finds a connection to each work of art.

Contact Us

We're not around right now. But you can send us an email and we'll get back to you, asap.

Not readable? Change text. captcha txt